data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/91c58/91c58aeaf72f6f0b355f38a525e51f0c65345e48" alt=""
Friday, March 07, 2008
Do 4WDs belong in cities?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/91c58/91c58aeaf72f6f0b355f38a525e51f0c65345e48" alt=""
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Community Action for Sustainable Transport Inc. (CAST) is a grassroots collective of Southeast Queensland (SEQ)residents and activists with an interest in sustainable transport policies and systems. We welcome new members who wish to contribute to the formulation and promotion of its policies, and to participate in its activities in SEQ.
2 comments:
I agree and think a carbon tax at registration time should be paid to help reduce the desire for heavy vehicles.
The only objection I have concerning 4WDs is that so many people spend above their means (go into debt) on unnecessary goods. Careless and unnecessary spending in this way harms our collective financial situation as a nation.
4WDs may serve for some people a similar function as a station wagon, ute or van. It is not necessary to have 4WD for most such purposes, but there is little difference in the size of vehicle. For some it may be a work or business vehicle. Some people use them for off-road recreational purposes.
For these people, using 4WDs also for normal travel may be the economical choice, since the alternative is to pay for the purchase, registration and maintenance of two vehicles.
Penalising these people with higher rego fees could just discourage them further from buying an additional, regular car for on-road travel. It would also be unfair to them - particularly if it is for work/business use.
Which is worse "environmentally" anyway - consuming more fuel and producing more emissions, or using more resources to manufacture more vehicles?
Many SUVs are quite small (e.g. RAV-4s) and are the size of an average car anyway. Even some bigger 4WDs (e.g. Toyota Hilux) have only 4-cyinder engines. A Falcon or Commodore has a 6 engine.
Government policy should be to stay out of people's private affairs so we can make the right choices for ourselves.
Post a Comment